Section 138 NI Act: Understand Cheque Bounce Cases

Introduction

A cheque bounce is not merely cheque bounce, but a financial hiccup that leads to serious legal consequences, including fines and even imprisonment. All must have the knowledge and understanding of the financial implications of a dishonoured cheque. Whether you are an individual, a businessman or a freelancer, section 138 NI Act is known as cheque bounce law to all. Let us delve deeper into our understanding of 10 things you must know about cheque bounce cases.

1. It is A Criminal Offence, Not Mere Civil Debt:

A prevalent misconception is that a cheque dishonour is merely a civil dispute for money recovery. Section 138 NI Act has classified the dishonour of a cheque as a criminal offence. This means a case filed under this section proceeds in a criminal court, typically before a Judicial Magistrate First Class or Metropolitan Magistrate. A conviction may lead to a criminal record for the accused.

2. Mens Rea Is Not Essential For Conviction

In any cheque bounce case, there is no need to prove that there was/was no guilty mind such as in other criminal cases. Unlike most criminal offences, where the prosecution must prove a guilty mind or malicious intent, Section 138 NI Act is governed by the principle of strict liability.

3. The Cheque’s Validity Period Is Now Just 3 Months

There is a common misconception that cheques are valid for six months, but after an RBI Notification dated 4^th November 2011. This period has been shortened to three months from the date of issuance of the cheque.

4. Strict Timelines For Notice And Complaint Filing Under Section 138 NI

There are strict timelines for filing a case under section 138 NI Act, this timeline may be cumulative in nature. The timelines must to be complied with. There is requirement for payee to issue a written demand notice to drawer within 30 days of receiving the bank’s dishonour memo. The date of receipt of information from the bank is excluded when calculating this 30-day period. After that the drawer has 15 days to make the payment. 

TO FILE A CHEQUE BOUNCE CASE, CONTACT SPECIALISED ADVOCATES AT LEGAL MAAMLA: https://legalmaamla.com/

5. Section 138 NI Act Applicable Only Legally Enforceable Debt:

A cheque bounce case is only valid if the cheque was issued in discharge of a “legally enforceable debt or other liability”. More importantly, a cheque issued for a “time-barred debt”—a debt older than 3 years for which no acknowledgement or payment was made, and thus legally unenforceable—cannot be recovered under Section 138.

6. The Burden Of Proof Shifts To The Accused To Disprove Debt:

Once the complainant successfully proves the basic elements of the offense, the law creates a reasonable presumption that the cheque was issued for a legally enforceable debt. The burden then shifts to the accused to disprove this presumption.

7. Court Can Order Interim Compensation In Trial:

The Negotiable Instruments (Amendment) Act, 2018 has been introduced, which is an important amendment empowering the court to direct the drawer to pay “interim compensation” to the payee/complainant. The interim amount can be up to 20% of the cheque amount and must be paid within 60 days. This provision can be invoked early in the trial.

Contact LegalMaamla Advocates To Get Interim Compensation In Your Case.

8. The Offence Is Compoundable:

Offences under Section 138 are “compoundable”, meaning the parties can reach an out-of-court settlement at any stage of the proceedings, even post-conviction. This allows the accused to avoid a criminal record and reduces litigation costs for both parties.

9. Penalties Can Be Double The Cheque Amount And Imprisonment:

The consequences of conviction under Section 138 are severe. The accused can be sentenced to imprisonment for a term which may extend up to two years, or a fine which may extend to twice the amount of the cheque, or both. 

10. Specific Defence Can Quash A Case In Section 138 NI:

There are certain reasons other than insufficient funds for quashing a case. Cheque Misuse, Bank Error, and Procedural Flaws are another set of grounds to quash the case. 

Conclusion: Section 138 NI Act

In conclusion, Section 138 NI Act is a strong but intricate legislative measure intended to preserve the integrity of financial transactions. It is crucial for both payees seeking justice and drawers defending against a complaint to comprehend these eleven lesser-known aspects. Such aspects can range from its criminal nature and strict liability to the crucial deadlines, the subtleties of “legally enforceable debt,” the shifting burden of proof, interim compensation, compounding complexities, severe penalties, diverse defences, and jurisdictional nuances. 

By:

Swarnav Biswas